fbpx

 

Be careful with the quality of the switches used for the engine power circuits. In an experimental airplane assembled in another country, with a Rotax 912iS engine, an intermittent failure appeared. The red Lane B and Lane A lights when starting the engine sometimes flashed, other times they stayed completely red, having to go back to the starting procedure. Other times in flight, Lane A or B's voltage ranged between quite different values. After investigating the problem, we found that the fault was in the quality of the toggle switches that had been installed. They were of such poor quality that did not support the Amps specified in Rotax installation manual. It is also important to copy the starting procedure recommended by Rotax in the Checklist, where both Lanes must always be turned on BEFORE giving Start Power. I attach some photographs of the switch and the internal contacts that were quite damaged, as well as a rivet that goes to the loose connection screw. When choosing a switch, we always take into account its Quality and the Amps it supports. We replaced al swtiches with MS35058 or MS35059 aviation grade swtiches. This is very critical in the LANES, Fuel Pump, Master and Start Power switches. And this is valid for other engines such as 915 and 916 also.

10608_1_WhatsApp Image 2024-09-29 at 20.26.20.jpeg (You do not have access to download this file.)
10608_1_WhatsApp Image 2024-09-29 at 20.26.19.jpeg (You do not have access to download this file.)
  • Re: Quality of Swtiches used for Engine Power

    by » one month ago


    Thanks for sharing this, I agree properly rated Mill Spec switches should be used.  As for the Rotax starting procedure, I would like to know the reason that both lane switches should be on before start power is applied.  I do it that way, I just don’t know why it’s better than turning the start power on first, then switching the lanes one at a time. 


  • Re: Quality of Swtiches used for Engine Power

    by » one month ago


    After just a few Hobbs hours of operation, I had to replace a certified Cessna Split Master Switch, just like the one below. 

    I have used automotive grade toggle switches for many years, without any problems. I would go so far as to suggest the Cessna switch was of inferior quality to the automotive ones.  The Cessna switch had some sort of internal resistance, causing overheating and eventual failure (luckily no fire) Anyhow the new one is functioning okay.

    Perhaps the lesson is  - manufacturing faults can and do occur, certifications no guarantee of quality.

     

    Main Image


  • Re: Quality of Swtiches used for Engine Power

    by » one month ago


    Found a photo of the cooked switch, showing overheated terminal;

     

     

    40611_2_IMG_3105.JPG (You do not have access to download this file.)

  • Re: Quality of Swtiches used for Engine Power

    by » one month ago


    I think this is the answer. When a switch closes, three phenomena occur for a few milliseconds: one mechanical (bounce) and the other two electrical (overvoltage oscilations, and small electric arcs on the contacts). When a load is connected, voltage oscillations are produced, sometimes significant. If a switch is closed without power at its terminals however, these voltage oscillations do not occur.

    CASE 1 (Incorrect) we first activate the START POWER and then the LANES. In this case the ECUs will receive voltage oscillations that can influence their rapid boot process and end in an error signal.

    CASE 2 (Correct) we activate the LANES first (without power) and then we give START POWER. In this case the ECUs do not receive the oscillations produced by the LAN switches but they do receive some from the Start Power switch, however, both ECUs receive them at the same time, and since the boot processes are very fast in these mission-critical computers, I understand that there are fewer failures in the boot process. In addition, there is constant communication between ECU A and ECU B, and this parallel process of giving energy to both at the same time can contribute to a better mutual starting process.

    By the way, choosing a very good switch for Start Power is essential (Installation manual section 24-00-00). For example Rotax requires that Start Power switch should be 20A.

    40613_2_Screen Shot 2024-09-30 at 06.11.25.png (You do not have access to download this file.)

    Thank you said by: Jeff Blakeslee

  • Re: Quality of Swtiches used for Engine Power

    by » one month ago


    Hi Maximo

    I believe you are correct.  The ECU has 2 computers and they are always looking to sync the pair.  The complete process of pairing, getting it in sync, takes just 720 degrees rotation.  2 turns of the crankshaft to calibrate crank angle and set the right injector and ignition for each cylinder.  As soon as start power to the circuit is on the fuse box powers all the sensors for cranking.  This I believe is the need for a good switch as called out in the installation manual. 

    Just some background for tech peeps who might like that. 

    Cheers


You do not have permissions to reply to this topic.